Why I think that you should keep the ops opped instead of following freenode’s recommendations.

Is there an issue with your IRC channel needing op attention? Without having ops visible, your users will very likely go to the network support channel instead of informing you or your ops.

Without ops being visible, who are ops or how to alert them?

  • /msg chanserv access #channel list
    • requires whoising all ops to see if they are present
      • idle time gets reset by CTCP replies, OTR and possibly other things. Freenode staffers also base their judgement on are there ops present to handle the issue on idletime of ops.
    • new users most likely have no idea on the command
    • remote (=different server) whois is rate-limited
  • /msg memoserv sendops #channel help! X is spamming
    • requires +A flag which isn’t mostly given to everyone
    • new users are unsure whether they have the flag if they even know about existense of the flag or the MemoServ command.

There is also third commonly used method, having trigger word that either highlights all the ops or makes bot PM or highlight the ops which again has it’s own issues:

  • are the ops surely highlighting on it?
  • the users can be confused for not getting any kind of acknowledging to the triggerword without bot and possibly spam it even more
  • if the bot PMs the ops, what if they are on umode +g and miss the bot?
  • if the bot highlights all the ops, what if the ops automatically ignore mass highlights (multiple nicks highlighted on the same line)?
  • and again, are the users aware of the triggerword?
    • if you clearly document it on webpage of your channel, the users should be aware of it, but what if they didn’t bother to read it or forgot it? Their fault probably, but your channel is having issues for longer time…

And there is also the issue of having to trust services or your bots. What if the services go down or netsplit and the same happens to your bot? You are out of luck unless you had the ops opped in which case the outage doesn’t affect you that much at all.

Fixing freenode

Tell ChanServ the following three commands:

/msg chanserv template #channel AOP !+AeoOtvV
/msg chanserv template #channel FOUNDER !+AFRefioOrstvV
/msg chanserv template #channel VOP !+AvV

The ! means “add these flags to everyone who currently matches the template exactly” so when you do this everyone who you have made xOP with `/msg chanserv someone xOP” gets opped or voiced automatically.
Note: templates including F (founder) are not automatically updated even with the !.

Alternatively if you have been setting flags manually use /msg chanserv flags #channel someone +O to automatically op them. You must also do this to yourself if you are channel founder, for auto-voicing use +V. Note: +o allows you to manually op/deop anyone, +v is the same, but for voice, so don’t confuse the casing.

Somewhat rewritten on 2015-04-28 13:25Z and now this looks even worse to my eyes… (Changelog)

2015-07-08: add fixing freenode.